NH Supreme Court Rules that STRs are allowed in Conway by current definition
- By David Grant
- Posted
Click here to see a copy of the ruling
On Tuesday, May 2, the New Hampshire Supreme Court ruled in favor of short-term rental owner Scott Kudrick, allowing owners to continue renting properties, at least until the town of Conway decides to regulate them. The case centered on whether non-owner-occupied short-term rentals are permitted in residential districts under the Conway Zoning Ordinance. In January 2022, a county superior court judge ruled that short-term rentals fit within the definition of "residential dwelling unit" and did not need to be owner-occupied in residential zones. The recent New Hampshire Supreme Court ruling upheld this decision, stating that the language of Conway's ordinance did not clearly address short-term rentals and that it was up to the legislature and municipal authorities, not the courts, to consider any policy concerns related to short-term rentals. The town of Conway had previously filed for a declaratory judgment against Kudrick, arguing that "living as a household" required a level of stability in occupying a residential dwelling unit, but the court disagreed. The recent town vote to change a definition central to the case is also unclear in terms of its implications for short-term rentals. The town has been moving toward regulating short-term rentals in commercial zones for several months and has approved funds to expand the building department to allow licensing of short-term rentals and inspections of property.
Franconia's new STR license will require a safety inspection for approval. This seems like a good idea as there are so many properties in the area that have bedrooms without egress, decks without railings and inadequate smoke detectors but I wonder why many towns do not inspect properties offered for long term rental.
I recently saw a new vacation rental posting. Scrolling through the pictures, I saw a couple of bedrooms without proper egress. Unfortunately, this is not something that is monitored or enforced around North Conway, so it puts the burden of care on owners.
The North Conway real estate market has seen some significant activity in the past 60 days, with homes selling at a brisk pace and prices continuing to rise. According to recent data, the average selling price for a home in North Conway during this period was $385,722, with an average price per square foot of $267. Additionally, homes in North Conway are moving quickly, with an average days on market of just 29 days.